The LLM Podcast

September 01, 2025
Next podcast at 09:30 IST
Abhinav Ennazhiyil

Rubén Amorim Under Intense Scrutiny as Manchester United Faces Dressing Room Doubts After Carabao Cup Shock

Carabao Cup Exit Ignites Crisis at Old Trafford: Amorim Under Fire

Manchester, England – The aftermath of Manchester United's stunning Carabao Cup elimination at the hands of League Two minnows Grimsby Town has plunged Old Trafford into a new crisis, with manager Rubén Amorim reportedly facing severe pressure and burgeoning doubts from within his own dressing room. The unexpected defeat has intensified scrutiny on the Portuguese coach, whose tactical approach and man-management skills are now being openly questioned.

Ruben Amorim took a massive body blow in midweek.

Shock Defeat to Grimsby Town Fuels Discontent

The Red Devils suffered a humiliating exit from the Carabao Cup, falling to Grimsby Town in a penalty shootout after squandering a 2-0 deficit to draw 2-2 in normal time. The result was a significant blow for a club that invested a substantial £21 million ($28.3 million) to bring Amorim to Old Trafford, and a further £200 million on new attacking talent this summer.

Amorim himself did not mince words after the defeat, expressing a stark assessment of his squad's performance. "Something has to change and you’re not going to change 22 players again," he stated, hinting at a potential loss of faith in his current roster. He also critically observed that the team started "without any intensity" and looked "completely lost," remarks that have only exacerbated concerns about a growing rift between the manager and his players.

Dressing Room Doubts and Board Backing (For Now)

Reports suggest that despite the mounting pressure, the Manchester United board, with the backing of co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe, currently intends to support Amorim. He is expected to remain in charge for Saturday's crucial match against Burnley. However, unnamed players are reportedly questioning his methods, and the efficacy of his tactics and man-management is now under intense debate.

The situation remains highly volatile, with speculation even suggesting that Amorim could consider resigning during the upcoming international break in September if the situation does not improve. Meanwhile, whispers of a potential return to Portugal for Amorim have also emerged. He has been linked with Sporting CP's rivals, Benfica, a club where he previously played. Presidential candidate João Noronha Lopes has publicly expressed his desire to appoint Amorim should he win the upcoming club elections, adding another layer of intrigue to the unfolding drama at Old Trafford.

As Manchester United grapples with this challenging period, all eyes will be on Amorim's ability to turn the tide and restore confidence both on and off the pitch.